News & Notes from the OpenDNS team

What's considered an adult site? Find out...

by John Roberts on Jun 12th, 2007

The famous quote about defining pornography is “I know it when I see it,” from a 1964 Supreme Court case. I’m glad we’re working with St. Bernard Software to get human-reviewed categorization of adult sites for our adult site blocking service.

At home, I’m the network administrator. While testing adult site blocking, I learned that you need to be careful what you block. My wife alerted (ahem) me to my overzealous blocking. For the interested, TMZ.com is classified as both lingerie/bikini and adult themes. :-) I cannot disagree… but it’s still a fun celebrity gossip site. It’s no longer blocked on my network, though other categories are.

That kind of control is useful, and it’s why we offer 6 categories, so you can make the right choices for your network.

Avoid making my domestic misstep. Check a site to find out whether it would be blocked, and why.

27 Responses

  1. Freddy

    A Whitelist feature would be cool :)

  2. Joe Siegler

    Agreed - an override for that would be helpful - was surprised that one of my regular sites was classified as “adult themes”, when it isn’t an adult or porn site or anything like that.

    Whitelist, please.

  3. Johannes

    Full ACK!

  4. Phil

    I second what Freddy says.

  5. Adam

    whitelist would be great. :)

  6. Marv Conn

    Whitelisting is the cure for over zealous categories. One of the problems I’ve faced in the past is that many blacklisting services blacklist things that don’t appear to be a problem. For example, many people say they can’t reach a popular hosting company’s website from work as it is blocked. A little control is all we really need.

    Thank you.

  7. John Roberts

    We’re listening. No promises on timeline or priority yet, but hearing specifics and interest is valuable.

  8. JT

    Yeah a whitelist would be a welcomed feature.

  9. David Szpunar

    I’ll chime in that a whitelist is definitely needed. To be useful in a corporate environment at least, a solution needs to be able to be overridden when someone higher-up says “why is that site blocked, and unblock it now okay?” If turning off the filtering (on one or more categories at least) is required to do this it’s not going to be fun. But it’s a very good first start, congrats! I’ve raved enough in my blog, I’ll stop now here :-)

  10. Devin

    I 2nd the white list option!

  11. Joachim

    How about some instrcutions what cllient to use on my Mac with 10.4?

  12. Richard Brookside

    I 2nd/3rd/4th/5th/6h and 7th the Whitelist request.

    Additionally, some sort feature that lets us dynamicall add/delete domains to be blocked/allowed for our specific network. For example, if I don’t want my kids to get to YOUTUBE or MYSPACE over for the weekend, I should be able to add that/those domain(s) so they are blocked.

    Lastly, a way we could block the google-cache would be useful. I have used that many times at work to get around their restrictive firewall rules.

    Thanks

  13. Adam

    Any chance of a bookmarklet, like the OpenDNS Cache Check? :)

  14. Will

    Wow

    I just found Open DNS Beats Telus dns hands down. I think a white list would be great but it may be too difficult to implement for free.

    192,290,208,735 dns requests all filtered through individual whitelists. CRAP!! :)

    It will be interesting to see if it can be pulled off!! It would definitely be the icing on what is already a great piece of cake.

    Thanks Guys for the service your providing

  15. Dick Hazeleger

    I agree with Will: It would be the icing on a beautful (and delicious) cake to have such a feature (Whitelist), however the implementation of such a feature could be very, very problematic if it were to be individual whitelists.

    I want to take the opportunity to thank the OpenDNS team for showing that the internet can be fast.. if you have the courage to drop your ISP’s DNS-servers; I did for an eMail program’s “Direct Delivery” feature (which needs two DNS-servers) and was so impressed by the speed the process then had, that I have set my TCP/IP’s DNS setting to OpenDNS as well, a step I so far haven’t regretted.

  16. Abraxias

    + whitelist :)

    and, I’d like to suggest adding:
    • “ATF” (Alcohol, Tobacco, Firearms & Explosives)
    • “Gambling”
    • “Adult Shopping”
    as categories to the Adult Site Blocking :)

  17. Movie: Knocked Up | clock — watching time, the only true currency

    […] Amusing side note: the official studio site was blocked by OpenDNS’s adult site blocking feature. Having seen the R-movie, I guess I’m not surprised, but it never occurred to me until I got the block page. Here at home, I just unblocked the “nudity” category, though, to view the site. You can check a site’s category for yourself with this domain checking tool. This new OpenDNS benefit we rolled out two weeks ago with St. Bernard has been very popular and very educational. […]

  18. Lee Munsil

    I’ve left a message on the OpenDNS forums (adult content) asking how do we communicate a porn site (really bad) that is not being blocked by iGuard/iPrism (whatever)? Explicit movies/pictures exist on the home page.
    I have also sent emails to iPrism support to ask the same question.

    I blocked out the name on my forums post. But you can check it out. I have also used your cache-checking link to confirm that “they” think the site is not an “adult content” site. They should look again.

  19. Abraxias

    I’d also like to suggest adding “Dating Services” as a category to the Adult Site Blocking.

  20. Abraxias

    here’s another Adult Site Blocking category suggestion that’s related to ATF, “drugs” (both legal & illegal: controlled substances, pharmaceuticals & narcotics)

  21. K Carey

    Fantastic Service!!!! As we have 3 small boys (ages 3, 5 & 7) I was trying to figure out a way to eliminate porn, etc from their accidental internet viewing experience / wanderings. I am very happy!

    However, if my wife wants to buy something from Victoria’s Secret it requires me going into the OpenDNS setup to temporarily allow viewing of that site. It would be nice if there was a way for her to enter a password (made in account setup) on the OpenDNS blocked page that would allow her access to the site to buy what she wanted. Is there any thought on adding this feature in the future?

    Thanks again!

  22. brian

    I just want fast DNS service. And I’m no longer getting that. I think you guys are becoming another one of those services that lose site of their original mission. And wasn’t that fast and reliable DNS service?

  23. Ilgaz

    Adult blocking is a nice step since most of those sites are also famous for using some real evil browser exploits whenever they are able to.

    OpenDNS needs sort of “Black hat” list from somewhere, a credible source and should enable that too.

    You would say “well let them don’t visit crack sites”, the “crack sites” also sometimes crack search engines to display their results instead of legitimate software. :) E.g. a scenario would be, non technical Graphics Artist looking for Adobe Photoshop CS3 help and hits crack site instead.

    Forget everything, there is famous and evil “iFrame” stories. You can search a credible site like Securityfocus.com or SANS for “iframe” and “exploit” and be amazed,no less.

  24. NovaSam

    Custom Set (overrides other sets, and would replace blocked domains)
    List domains you would like to allow or block

    This way you can have your white list and black list in the same section.

    Also I agree with K Carey,

    It would be nice to be able to put in a password to override the filtering when needed, Any Ideas?

  25. ChamPro

    Hmmmm, nasa.gov is blocked, but it doesn’t show up in the search.

  26. John Roberts

    @ChamPro — check your blocked domains list and read this

    http://www.opendns.com/support/article/181

  27. usama

    very thanks for members open dns

Leave a Reply

Subscribe

RSS Feed

Get email updates:

Most Recent Posts

Search

OpenDNS Button

Use OpenDNS

Use this button on your site!

Archives

Categories